.

Mamas Say: Enough with “Call of Duty!"

Which side of the battle over the “Call of Duty” video game are you on—‘It’s okay for my kids to play.’ Or ‘Over my dead body!’

 

I’ve been writing this column long enough now that strangers and friends regularly suggest topics they want me to cover. 

“Do something about those out of control parent coaches! They’re just awful and now they’re screaming at the student refs!”

“You should see the texts that my daughter gets sent—and she’s only in sixth grade!  Write something called ‘Sexting in Sixth Grade.’”

“Who gives their kid a cell phone in third grade—and it’s an iPhone?!  Write about how privileged kids in this part of the country are.”

At a recent girls’ night out, the topic turned to the “Call of Duty.”  My friend started the conversation:  “Please, Heather. Write about ‘Call of Duty.’ Tell other moms they need to agree to stop letting their kids play.  So when I say ‘No!’ to my children, I won’t be the only one saying ‘No!’.”

Mentioning the often violent, war-based video game series, this one mom effectively tossed a live grenade into the middle of the circle of moms, but rather than scatter from the impact, suddenly everyone jumped into the conversation. People who thought the game was inappropriate for kids were clamoring to agree, drowning out the odd silence of those who thought it was okay for their kids to play it.

“Call of Duty” is a video game series focusing on different wars, ranging from World War II to fictional modern battles. The game shows explicit violence and graphic content—throat slashing, knifeplay, automatic weapons shooting bullets that rip through flesh, and grenades that blow off limbs. That’s just the tip of the iceberg.

There is adult language, and there is graphic, mature imagery, such as torture and suicide bombings.

The first time I heard that a peer of my 10-year-old son played “Call of Duty” at home was two years ago—they were in the third grade. They were eight years old at the time.

Eight. An “interesting” age to introduce the topic of suicide bombers and what limbs look like when they get blown off by a grenade, don’t you think?

Of course, “Call of Duty” has a parent-control filter to reduce the amount of gore and profanity kids can experience when they play.  So “f*** you” becomes “screw you.”  That’s up to you as a parent to decide which version is okay for your child, if it’s even okay at all.

But, I’m not so sure that it’s up to you to decide which version is okay for my child, if it’s okay at all.

And therein is really the topic of this column, and what my friend was getting at when she suggested I broach the “Call of Duty” topic in this column. When you determine what’s okay for your own child, presumably you, the parent, have the best interests of your child in mind when deciding if he or she is up for playing a video war game.

Parental Miscommunication

It’s a completely different story when that choice is made on behalf of someone else’s child, without thought to consult that child’s parents.

We’ve all likely had that experience. You pick your child up from a friend’s house, and you find out that the kids have done something you’re completely not comfortable with—riding ATVs, watching an R-rated movie, or checking out the dad’s sword collection (that one really happened to someone I know).

Scary thing—you never heard from the other parent ahead of time to make sure the activity was okay with you.

I once wrote a column about something I pledged to do for my kids when they went over to a friend’s house—to ask each time whether there was a gun in the house where my child had been invited.

I got a lot of flak for writing that column—sadly, I was misunderstood by many readers who thought I was speaking out against the right to own firearms. On the contrary, I had no beef with people who chose to legally own guns. I was just writing about opening up the conversation between two adults who might need to take responsibility for the time each other’s children were spending in one another’s homes, and understanding what kinds of things their kids might encounter.

Parents can choose how they want to parent their own children.  But when they’re making choices that affect other people children, that’s where it gets dicey.

This is territory we parents tread into all the time, not just with violent video games. Another friend told me of a time her son went to a friend’s house directly after school, and was staying for a sleepover.  She never received a call from the other parent letting her know her son had arrived in one piece. When she phoned, the call went to voice mail, and there was no word about how things were going, if they even were. She didn’t get a return call, even after leaving a message.

Thankfully that situation turned out fine. The only lasting effect is the mental note my friend has made about how responsible—or not—the other parent is and whether she’ll ever let her child go over to that house again.

I had a situation arise over the past weekend where I needed to make the judgment call about something that happened on a playdate my daughter had, and whether or not I needed to inform the parents of my daughter’s friends.

During a conversation the two 6-year-old girls had in front of me, they mentioned that a boy on their bus often said, “Sexy! Sexy!” Then my daughter’s friend asked me, “Mrs. Herve, what does ‘sexy’ mean?”

I deflected it as best as I could—telling her that it was a grown up word that didn’t really belong in school, or on a school bus, or with kids who were six. But it was probably better if she had the conversation with her own parents.

That kind of conversation is sensitive enough to have with your own children, but when it gets introduced with a child who isn’t your own, it’s likely not something you should tackle.

But at the first possible opportunity, you can bet that I called the little girl’s mom, to tell her what happened.

Some parents might not have thought it was important enough to mention. Some might think me prudish. But when it comes to the responsibility I have for children who are visitors in my home, I have to acknowledge the responsibility I have to keep their parents informed and to let their parents set the boundaries.

So too does that apply to “Call of Duty.” Maybe it’s one of those things I need to add to the list of topics to chat about before each get together my kids have. Can we talk about what movie they’re going to watch during the sleepover? Is it possible to limit the amount of time they play video games, and by the way, can you limit it to sports-themed ones? How about they stay off the ATVs?

I can already hear the comments from those who disagree with me: “Don’t be such a helicopter parent! Relax, HBH, your kids will be fine, it’s nothing we didn’t hear or see when we were growing up and we turned out okay.”  I might even hear, “Your kid’s gonna grow up to be a wuss! I want my child to see the reality of the world.”

People who feel that way are completely entitled to their opinions. But it’s up to me to make those choices for my children, just as it’s their choice to decide for theirs.

RONALD M GOLDWYN October 10, 2012 at 01:05 PM
During the past almost 100 years, the USA has been at peace for only 5 - 10 years, mainly in the 50's between Korea and Viet Nam wars. During WWII almost every kid played soldier and had toy guns to play with. In 1946 TV arrived and the channels were filled with the grade B westerns that originally were seen at the movies. Many of the radio shows migrated to TV, but violence and killing filled the lives of kids. Don't forget the 10¢ comic books that went so wild that the public demanded a Board of Approval to rate the appropriateness of them. Can you remember that in 1954 the first transistor radio hit the market (Regency) Until then radios were like later boom boxes, but with huge high voltage batteries. Then came the 60's and movies started to be rated as to age that could be seen by children alone. All this time toy guns were filling rows in toy stores and 5¢ & 10¢ stores. In the mid 70's the first home computers arrived with the first electronic games. (Pong) Now kids could stay indoors and play alone. Today the electronic games are like the comic books of the 50's where the morality of our society is at stake. Eliminate war and the subject matter of our toys will also change.
MCF January 03, 2013 at 02:32 PM
I 'played' war growing up (using our fingers as guns and making bang, bang sounds to indicate firing the 'weapon'), watched the very violent Warner Brothers cartoons (Bugs Bunny and Gang). Yet, I don't own or like guns and I'm not yet compelled to become an owner. However, after Newtown, I considered what violence my children are exposed to (my oldest daughter is a Call of Duty master - she kicks my butt when we play) and I thought maybe it's time to stop with that game and steer her in another direction. After Newtown I began to think that violence in society is the cause of the violent outbursts and then it occurred to me that maybe mental illness is the cause of violent acts not violence itself. I know it sounds ridiculous but the truth is we can't stop mentally ill people from carrying out violent acts, that is part of their illness. We can't stop them from getting guns - the legality and banning or not of weapons won't stop someone from obtaining them. The answer isn't arming more people, I'm paranoid enough about public places now. The very best we as a society can do is pay closer attention to our children, love them unconditionally - does not mean spoiling them but teaching them by example (that's our primary responsibilty) - reflect on the meaning of unconditional and leading by example and don't ever be afraid as a parent to act in the best interest of your child AND yourself by seeking professional assistance when necessary. There is no shame in humility.
jungis4545 January 03, 2013 at 07:11 PM
'Call of Duty' at eight years old? Oh, the horror. My twin boys and I watched 'Full Metal Jacket' when they were eight. Look, bad things sometimes happen to people, whether it's some a-hole with a rifle, a drunk driver, a serious disease, or a broken leg while playing. The real world is out there, like it or not. My boys heard the call of duty with 9/11, and after high school were Marines in the thick of it. I couldn't be more proud.

Boards

More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »